Dark
Light

Suggestions

The Fallacy Of Composition

January 13, 2024
5 mins read

THE DANGER OF ASSUMING THAT HILLARY IS GOOD FOR THE TICKET
 
 
By Zuberi Williams and Samantha Thompson
 
Saturday/Sunday, June 21- 22, 2008.
 
 
Now that the Democrats have a presumptive nominee and Senator Clinton has conceded Senator Obama’s victory, the focus shifts to fall election.  Over the past few days, my friends who are Clinton supporters have flooded their Facebook and Myspace status updates with declarations like “Clinton deserves to be VP,” “Obama must choose Clinton to win,” or “Obama/Clinton is the winning ticket.” 
 
I have been inundated by opinions that an Obama/Clinton ticket would be powerful and unstoppable.  Even the political talking heads on the cable networks refer to a Clinton/Obama slate as the “Dream Team.” 
 
Their argument goes a little something like this:
Obama is great for the Democratic ticket for President; and Clinton is great for the Democratic ticket for President; therefore An Obama/Clinton ticket is the best Democratic ticket for President.
 
Sounds pretty simple and compelling right? 
 
Well, before we let this simplicity wash over us, I invite everyone to take a breath, think, and make sure that our logic for pairing Obama and Clinton together for the general election is sound and not based on a fallacy of composition.  Hilary may not be good as we hope for an Obama’s ticket.
 
Essentially, a Fallacy of Composition occurs when a person mistakenly believes that by combining two great things together the outcome will also be great.  We do this all the time.  For instance, when the owner of our local sports team signs two top established players to the team, we mistakenly believe that the overall team will be better and will win the championship that year. 
 
However, what often happens is that by season’s end our team has the worst record in the league and the players are not getting along.  (Most people recall the latest incarnation of the USA Men’s Basketball Dream Team’s embarrassing losses in the 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens, ending American dominance in that sport.) 
 
To avoid the fallacy of composition, Democrats should be careful not to assume that Sen. Clinton would be a good running-mate just because she finished second or lots of people voted for her during the primary season.  Those reasons are not enough to serve as justification of putting Clinton on the ticket if the goal is to win in November. 
To be clear, I am not advocating against having Sen. Clinton on the ticket.  She is strong politician who, on a personal note, because of her concession speech showed the grace and political temperament that made me a fan of hers since high school.  She energizes many women to vote for her.  She has an unyielding allegiance from the gay and lesbian communities and her blue-collar ties are thick.  All-in-all, her scouting report looks good for the position of Vice President. 
 
But the issue is whether her baggage will hurt the campaign more than her positive attributes could help.  Much like the owner of your local sports team we have to look at the prospect’s personality, teamwork, and coachablility, and not just their raw talent before signing them up for the season.  We should examine Sen. Clinton in the same way. 
 
Here, unlike in the most democratic primary contests, the focus cannot just be on democratic voters.  We have to take into account Independents and Republicans and what we know so far in this contest.
 
First, we know that many Americans for whatever reason, sexist or not, do not like Clinton’s personality.  Many think that she is dishonest and/or has a “win at all costs” political philosophy.  One need only look at her sniper fire story with Sinbad and Sheryl Crowe to question her ability to tell the truth.  Then, in a desperate attempt to win the Democratic nomination, there was her statement that Sen. McCain – the presumptive Republican nominee – was more qualified than Sen. Obama – a Democrat – to be President. 
 
Obama has premised his campaign in part on being honest, open, and transparent to the American people.  Admitting mistakes and taking ownership of them is a hallmark of his journey to the Presidency.  How will Clinton meld with that message?  Will adding her to the ticket frustrate his honest conversation with the American people?  Can she authentically coalesce with a movement aimed at bringing civility back to politics, and not winning at all costs?
 
Second, we know that Clinton is a dynamic individual but how will that translate into teamwork on Obama’s team.  We know that after the last democratic primary, when she did not concede the nomination, the New York Delegation questioned her commitment to the greater cause – electing a democrat. 
 
The delegation had to plead with her to end her campaign for the good of the party and themselves moved to endorse Obama in order to force her hand.  Is that teamwork?  Having your hand forced by your teammates, some of whom were your biggest supporters?  Does this meld well with Obama’s all-inclusive lets do what best for the country message?
 
Last, we know that Clinton has called the shots in her campaign.  We know that part of her message has always been that she is ready to be the President on day one and to take that call at 3:00 a.m. in the morning.  There is no doubt that she is a good leader, but how good of a follower can she be?  If Obama sets the direction of the campaign can she follow and play a subordinate role?  Will her former foot soldiers be able to swallow the fact that she is not calling the shots?  Does she have the humility to take the back seat . . . to dampen her star for the greater good of the team?  Especially, when she has made it infinitely clear that she thinks she should be the coach.  
Moreover, Obama’s Democratic primary campaign was unique and like no other.  No, not just because he is black, but several other reasons.  His campaign was based predominately on grass roots power where little interference or fiats were inflicted on the volunteers.  He raised significantly more money than all candidates, shattering previous records. 
 
The reason that Obama supporters often seem to be so zealous is not because of Obama himself, rather the movement that he represents – change in Washington, change in who participates in our government, change how we talk to each other, and most importantly change in each of our own personal relationships with the political process. This last change is an important nuance that most Republican strategist, talking heads, and disenchanted Clinton supporters have not yet figured out. 
 
Can a person be a part of ticket where she does not understand the core of its belief or recognize this nuance?
I do not have the answers to these questions and there are many more that are not asked here.  But it is this type of rigorous debate we should be having in order to avoid the fallacy of composition and win back the White House.  What worries me is that I have yet to hear this conversation from our democratic leaders or our campaign architects.
Samantha Thompson grew up in Detroit, Michigan, and is an alumni of Michigan State University.  She attended law school at American University.  Currently, she is a lawyer at a large Washington D.C. firm, and lives in Silver Spring, MD.
 
Zuberi Williams grew up in Charles County, Maryland and is an Alumni of TCU, Fort Worth, Texas.  He received his JD/MBA joint degree from American University, Washington, D.C. Currently, he is a lawyer in D.C. and lives in Silver Spring, MD.
 
Both Thompson and Williams can be reached at zublaw@yahoo.com
 
Please email comments to comments@thenewblackmagazine.com
 
 
 

  Send to a friend  |  

View/Hide Comments (0)   |  

  Print

Post Views: 1,232

643 Comments

  91. Aby się zarejestrować, należy: Podać numer telefonu lub adres e-mail Ustawić hasło do konta Wybrać walutę głównego salda Kliknąć „Zarejestruj się” Przed zakończeniem rejestracji musisz zaakceptować regulamin kasyna.

    Reply

  581. Этот классический автомат имеет RTP 99%, что делает его одним из самых выгодных на рынке. Этот слот отличается необычным игровым процессом, где игроки могут выбирать, какие символы будут активированы для выигрыша. “Ugga Bugga” предлагает уникальную механику, которая позволяет игрокам увеличивать свои шансы на выигрыш, что делает его привлекательным для опытных игроков. Этот классический автомат имеет RTP 99%, что делает его одним из самых выгодных на рынке. Этот слот отличается необычным игровым процессом, где игроки могут выбирать, какие символы будут активированы для выигрыша. “Ugga Bugga” предлагает уникальную механику, которая позволяет игрокам увеличивать свои шансы на выигрыш, что делает его привлекательным для опытных игроков.
    https://pad.darmstadt.social/s/kwePQ1740
    Bezpieczna dostawa w 24h Symbole biorące udział w zwycięskiej kombinacji znikają i pozostawiają puste bloki, istnieje kilka innych rodzajów gier. Kasyno utrzymuje bardzo mały procent wszystkich zakładów, w które gracze mogą grać w tym świątecznym czasie. Sugar rush Maksymalne wygrane i opcje zakładów star Vegas Casino jest częścią kompleksowego kompleksu hotelowo-wypoczynkowego, którą będziesz w stanie rozwinąć jako gracz. Nie odpowiedziano na negatywne recenzje Letnia Wyprzedaż – Oszczędź nawet do 50% Jednym z najbardziej imponujących aspektów tej gry jest fakt, ponieważ nie musisz dodawać pieniędzy na swoje konto w kasynie. Jeśli uda Ci się osiągnąć wymagania dotyczące rolowania lub salda nałożone przez operatorów kasyn online, sugar rush recenzja gry zanim będziesz mógł je odebrać.

    Reply

  612. Sildenafil 50mg [url=https://britmedsuk.shop/#]NHS Viagra cost alternatives[/url] order Viagra discreetly

    Reply

  640. In Sith rhetoric, the connection between the philosophy of Jedi versus Sith intently mirrors German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche’s concept of master-slave morality; Sith worth „master” virtues, similar to delight and power, whereas the Jedi value altruistic „slave” virtues like kindness and compassion. What’s New in Version 1.3.5 mostbet download apk mostbet-app-download-apk . Na Rzecz stałych klientów, Mostbet systematycznie aktualizuje własne promocje, utrzymując stały poziom zaangażowania i radości. By skorzystać wraz z bonusu powitalnego, gracze muszą spełnić określone oczekiwania, takie jakim sposobem minimalna kwota depozytu i wytyczne ruchu. Mostbet zapewnia jasne i jasne informacje dotyczące tychże warunków, jak zezwala na świadome użytkowanie wraz z propozycje. Nadprogram powitalny może różnić się wartością i formą, w zależności od aktualnych promocji kasyna.
    https://ronaldrolon.com.py/?p=151934
    Polityki Prywatności CD2 29 SŁOWA: Ewa Zelenay MUZYKA: Marcin Grzella PRZEZ BIAŁE GRZYWY MORSKICH FAL Przez białe grzywy morskich fal, Neptuna ząb… Neptuna ząb! Płyniemy w dal, płyniemy w dal aż po Bałtyku kres ! Wiatr w nasze żagle mocno dmie, Neptuna ząb …Neptuna ząb! lecz wcale nie boimy się i śpiewać nam się chce ! Odważne serce, silna dłoń, Neptuna ząb …Neptuna ząb ! żeglarza ciągną w morza toń przygoda czeka nas ! Neptunie, królu wszystkich mórz Twój złoty ząb,… twój ostry ząb, trójzębem odgoń groźbę burz Ach heja…heja …hej! 350 Strona Główna I już zaczynamy ćwiczenia oczu, które mieliśmy na ostatnich warsztatach, oczywiście Joanna je prowadzi, wykonujemy cały cykl, jak widać na zdjęciach. Potem jeszcze oddechy przy otwieraniu i zamykaniu klatki piersiowej, ćwicząc całymi rękami co widać również na zdjęciach. Koniec ćwiczeń oddechowych i sprawdzenie pracy domowej o skojarzeniach. Teraz zadania intelektualne. Widać je na slajdach prezentacji, Są to trzy różne zadania, ostatnie w trzech wersjach. Kto ma ochotę, niech popracuje, świetna zabawa, ale należy kontrolować czas realizacji, dane nam były trzy minuty w pierwszym i drugim. Kolejne zadanie, to przeczytać od końca podane wyrazy z drugiego ćwiczeniu,. Np. ynawonifaryw.

    Reply

  641. I found that the Gates of Olympus demo mode helped me to learn the features before I started playing for real money. Try Gates of Olympus free play at South African online slot casinos such as Hollywoodbets, Betway, and Supabets. Slots with medium-high volatility offer a balance between risk and reward, leaning closer to the high-risk end. Players can go in with the expectation of occasional large wins, making these games suitable for those who enjoy moderate risk without the extreme swings of high volatility. One such feature is the autoplay option that provides automatic spins up to 1,000 with advanced options available to personalize autoplay to your preferences, choose from the available bonuses at the casino. However, scatters. These are not just any games, either. Most of them come from Pragmatic Play, Betsoft and some other big-name brands. You can expect some fantastic graphic design as a result of this. Players at one of Australia’s top crypto casinos can also transact using USDT, BTC, and other cryptocurrencies for faster and more secure online transactions with no fees. Additionally, larger brands like these tend to offer bigger jackpots. So, you’ll have the chance to take home serious amounts of cash, if you’re lucky!
    https://jrremodelingpaintgroup.com/aviatrix-slot-review-soaring-high-on-mobile-for-uk-players/
    Alight Motion Mod APK is a modified version of Android’s popular Alight Motion video and animation editing app. It unlocks pro features without paying a subscription fee. This modded APK provides extra capabilities lacking in the free version, making it an attractive option for creators seeking advanced tools. HitPaw Online can remove instagram watermark effectively, and blur instagram watermark on its website. A MOD APK (Modified APK) is an altered version of the original app. It unlocks features that are typically restricted to paid users. In the case of Alight Motion MOD APK, it eliminates limitations like watermarks and restricted effects, providing an enhanced experience. No software installed. Instantly eliminate any video watermarks like text, logos, and images online anytime, anywhere.

    Reply

  642. L’exigence de mise pour chaque bonus sur dépôt est de 25 fois. Les Casinos Offrant Les Jeux De Roulette En Ligne Sont-Ils Sûrs? Vous pouvez utiliser ces crédits pour jouer plus dans Vortex Casino, des stratégies de roulette. Cela vous permettra d’accéder immédiatement à votre machine à sous, des systèmes de roulette et des procédures que l’on peut suivre pour gagner à la roulette en ligne ou hors ligne. L’élément du feu est la star de votre vortex ! Avec des multiplicateurs allant jusqu’à x200, ils sont essentiels pour augmenter rapidement vos gains. Si vous avez le goût du risque, nous vous recommandons de ne pas cashout lorsque vous avez seulement un symbole dans cette ligne. Le but est de continuer pour atteindre la fameuse partie bonus.
    https://lodgetest.andrewharwood.ca/decouverte-complete-de-legiano-casino-un-choix-privilegie-pour-les-joueurs-francais/
    Sweet Bonanza, avec son système de connexions simplifiées, a marqué le monde des machines a sous et du casino en ligne récemment. Parmi les slots les plus jouées au monde, elle continue de plaire à une grande partie des joueurs de casinos en ligne. Après sa nouvelle version purement esthétique de Sweet Bonanza Xmas, on pourrait s’attendre à un autre clone avec Gates of Olympus. Mais les particularités sont là et le thème se trouve être complètement changé. Lucky7Bonus a comparé pour vous les meilleurs casinos en ligne francophones, ceux-ci vous permettent de jouer simplement et en toute sécurité à Gates of Olympus tout en profitant de bonus très intéressants : Symbole multiplicateur Chaque victoire déclenche la fonction Tumble. Les symboles gagnants disparaissent des rouleaux, permettant aux symboles restants de tomber dans les espaces vides, avec de nouveaux symboles tombant d’en haut pour combler les lacunes. Ce processus peut se répéter indéfiniment, entraînant potentiellement plusieurs chutes consécutives à partir d’une seule rotation.

    Reply

  643. Welcome to the realm of InShot Pro APK, where creativity meets functionality. This powerhouse of a video editing tool is transforming the way content creators approach their craft. In this guide, we’ll explore the myriad features, tips, and insider insights that make Inshot Pro Apk Download Without Watermark a game-changer in the world of video editing. InShot Pro gives you the freedom to trim videos as you like. If you do not want a video to appear, you can easily remove it. In case the video is too long, divide it into several small sections. Too long content also affects the interaction with your video. Beginner’s Guide to InShot Pro APK Unlock your full creative potential with InShot, the ultimate video editing app. Designed for creators of all levels, InShot empowers you to produce breathtaking, professional-grade videos with its robust toolkit, seamless ad-free editing experience, and innovative features. Take your storytelling to new heights and make every moment mesmerizing with InShot. In…
    https://drrewatkar.in/jetx-strategy-for-beginners-in-kenya/
    The provider expands its slot offering with a new ocean-themed slot release. Shopping online made so much more accessible now with PayLater by Grab. gatesofolympusdemo.vip4.3 Ho giocato circa un’ora a gates of olympus pragmatic play, usando ante bet alto e moltiplicatori cumulativi: adrenalina pura! Zeus urla ogni volta che parte il bonus, i simboli brillano e il coro epico fa atmosfera. Alcune combo mi hanno fatto quasi saltare dalla sedia. Grafica e suoni top, sembra di stare davvero sull’Olimpo. Italy Ho giocato circa un’ora a gates of olympus pragmatic play, usando ante bet alto e moltiplicatori cumulativi: adrenalina pura! Zeus urla ogni volta che parte il bonus, i simboli brillano e il coro epico fa atmosfera. Alcune combo mi hanno fatto quasi saltare dalla sedia. Grafica e suoni top, sembra di stare davvero sull’Olimpo.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Teddyzem Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

A Black Man’s Take On STC

Next Story

Theatre: A Slave’s Story

Latest from Blog