Dark
Light

Suggestions

The Audacity of ‘Precious’

January 13, 2024
5 mins read

PRECIOUS IN THE CLASSROOM
By Aisha S. Durham
Saturday, December 12, 2009.Tuesday, I offered my black popular culture students a course summary. In the midst of reviewing the varied approaches employed to describe black popular culture from Hall, hooks and Darnell Hunt to Rose, Neal and Gwendolyn Pough, I stopped myself to ask the class what they thought of Precious.Their comments echoed much of the preferred cultural criticism from institutional voices surrounding the film. They readily spotted controlling images, they critiqued ghetto-centricity and ghetto-realism in black cinema, they described the popular production of black women’s stories as told by men (making connections to Spike Lee, Tyler Perry, Steven Spielberg ), and they identified the ideological work used to construct the preferred reading of individual triumph sans structural/institutional support; and for the students who proclaimed (with added grunts, rolling eyes, and lip smacks) they would not watch a film that could make us look bad (i.e., black folks who look bad to white people), they had handy, ready-made speeches replete with age-old racial uplift rhetoric about positive/negative images.
Both groups sat resolute in their “reading” of the film—demonstrating to me that they could apply the course material to engage critically with a media product. They anticipated my you-done-good smile. But, I took a breath and leaned over the laptop to announce:I liked Precious.With three words, I risked unraveling my tightly woven media/cultural studies course. On the final day of class, I had run the risk of losing credibility from my black feminist media studies teachers in training. Yet, in that moment, I had to run off course from my scripted notes to address the un/predictability of Precious and the implications of my empathetic re-reading of the film for media studies.The Un/Predicability of PreciousFirst, I liked Precious for reasons other than its emotive, evocative rhetoric of struggle that recalls what some have dubbed poverty porn. Precious offers racial sincerity and a class sensibility without announcing itself as real or some authentic re-presentation of black urban life. There are varied depictions of blackness in conversation with one another, which disrupts the singularly focused and celebrated come-up, overcome narrative that makes it commercially viable. Visually, Daniels undercuts minor narrative arcs by splicing “real” violence with fantasy (i.e., real-fantasy as an escape from violence and real-fantasy to re-imagine another way of being in the world), and by using the voice of Precious as the narrator and the voice-over that interrupts and disrupts institutional voices (e.g., the teacher, the case worker) speaking for her and about her.The institutional voices are the voices of authority—the ones who are heard. What we hear from some institutional voices in the popular is that moviegoers should read the book to appreciate or denounce the film (i.e., read the book to read the film accurately). What we hear from some institutional voices in the academy is that we should know the social facts or the statistical realities to talk about the un/realness of this story. Both of these responses assume stories—as social fact or fiction—get us closer to some knowable truth when each of them (with their own codes and conventions), use numbers, words and images to tell a story. And it is because of these voices that I imagine that a “Precious” could never be heard. She can only stand-in for or represent positions that already call her body into being.As a media studies scholar, I am interested in what story is being told and whose story is being heard. From weeklong conversations about the film, it would seem the story depends on who you ask. Some identified with the teacher, the caseworker, the daughter. Few could digest the mother as both victim and victimizer. As a baby who was nicknamed Precious because of my mother’s perceived overprotection and as a the professor with educational capital who still carries a form of ghetto girl class consciousness from my public housing community in Norfolk (VA) to the university halls of College Station (TX), I found myself shifting viewing positions and aligning myself with different characters, which speaks to the multiplicity of blackness present and the competing stories that drew me to Precious in the first place.
There can be multiple stories. There can be multiple stories. There can be multiple stories. What Precious reveals is the cultural politics surrounding class for black folks—especially those consumed with the omnipresence of whiteness. (Here, I am reminded of other discussions about hip hop and even some of my own commentary about Tyler Perry for that matter.) Here, class as a differential consciousness remains a thorny subject in media studies because there is an assumption that we agree on what constitutes the black popular proper. After hearing my own voices and those of homegirls and students, I am left to wonder when do the working class have “permission” to speak about lived realities and how do we really account for multiple representations of blackness in the black public sphere?Second, I liked Precious because it does illuminate the impact of the patriarchal state vis-à-vis violence. Violence is structural and systemic through poverty, institutional and disciplinary through the welfare, juvenile justice and educational system, and interpersonal through emotional, physical and sexual, and verbal abuse and aggression. (And, yes those are interrelated.) The life chances of the poor black women in the film are deeply impacted by their navigation through and their cooperation with the state. Food, shelter and family cohesion are tied to (or severed by) the state.
Precious must perform a re-victimization for the caseworker to “get her check” while performing acceptable black motherhood for another caseworker to keep her kid(s). The state commands the performance while simultaneously using these “acts” as evidence of black pathology. While national discussions about the state has routinely addressed the lived realities of black men, Precious forcefully depicts the significant role of the state in the policing and surveillance of poor black females.
These are vulnerable bodies whose privates (body, home and otherwise) can be invaded, used and abandoned. As domineering as the Mary mother figure appears, she too is a victim of these varied modes of violence. I watched the film thinking about our inability to see anything redeeming in Mary speaks to our inability to see poor black women in general as vulnerable, as victim. Precious calls attention to the state of some poor black women by highlighting heteropatriarchal state/violence.I came to Precious thinking that I knew the story, that I knew her story. I was prepared—like my students—to be a mad black woman because the stereotypes do exist in the film, and do perform the ideological work of the state. The cultural criticism highlighting the two is warranted. My reading shouldn’t contest it. Instead, my reading asked me to consider how these cinematic representations gain meaning.
`I left Precious thinking how and why is Precious so meaningful to me? The film invited me to access modes of differential consciousness in the same way that I was drawn to forms of hip hop to announce that I was a hip hop feminist years ago. Ultimately, Precious pushed me to hear another story—an unlikely and disliked one. And it is because of this push, I interrupted myself (and the student echo) in the classroom. Tuesday, I thought—for one moment—that there could be another Precious story to tell.
With thanks to  New Black Man.Aisha S. Durham is the co-editor of the books Home Girls, Make Some Noise!: A Hip-Hop Feminism Anthology and Globalizing Cultural Studies: Ethnographic Interventions in Theory, Method & Policy. Durham is Assistant Professor of Communications and Africana Studies at Texas A&M University.

  Send to a friend  |  

View/Hide Comments (0)   |  

  Print

Post Views: 1,879

389 Comments

  22. online canadian pharmacy reviews [url=https://expressrxcanada.shop/#]canadian pharmacy victoza[/url] best canadian pharmacy online

    Reply

  26. escrow pharmacy canada [url=http://expressrxcanada.com/#]Canadian pharmacy shipping to USA[/url] canadian pharmacy 24h com

    Reply

  29. mexico pharmacy order online [url=https://rxexpressmexico.com/#]mexican online pharmacy[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

    Reply

  95. antibiotic without presription [url=https://biotpharm.shop/#]Biot Pharm[/url] Over the counter antibiotics for infection

    Reply

  107. get antibiotics quickly [url=https://biotpharm.shop/#]buy antibiotics online uk[/url] buy antibiotics from india

    Reply

  109. With our mobile-friendly casino, you can play mobile casino games when you’re on the go. Simply log on to bovada.lv from your smartphone or tablet, and the mobile-optimized version of our casino will appear on your screen. The same carousels (Most Popular, Live Dealer, Blackjack, Table Games, Slots, and Video Poker) exist in both the desktop casino and the mobile versions, making it easy to navigate. Level up your online casino play with live dealer games. These immersive games bring the casino floor to you, showcasing a thrilling range of unique takes on classic table games or game shows filled with side bets and variations to keep the games fresh and exciting. Play with a real-life dealer and players for the chance to win big cash prizes. Live casino games generally offer larger bet limits, making it ideal for higher-stakes players.
    https://littlescholar.in/2025/05/27/top-aviator-gaming-sites-ranked-by-indian-users-in-2025/
    Mar 02, 2021 App Description Slotomania VIP is playtika,slotomania,cards,casino, content rating is High Maturity (PEGI-18). This app is rated 4 by 4 users who are using this app. The Slotomania VIP Inner Circle is a unique loyalty program offered by Slotomania, a popular social casino game. In this program, Slotomania provides enhanced benefits and perks to its most dedicated players. Apart from the regular Slotomania app which is available on the Google Play store, there is another VIP app for Slotomania which can be downloaded from slotomaniavip Play across devices: iOS, Android, Facebook, and zyngapoker Slotomania VIP app or Inner Circle platform is an exclusive app and when you play on the Slotomania VIP app, you will have additional benefits for being a VIP player for which you have worked hard.

    Reply

  110. Die Begriffe: „Schattenlotterie“, „Schwarze Lotterie“ oder „Zweitlotterie“ bedeuten, dass Sie über einen Zwischenanbieter auf die Ergebnisse einer „echten“ Lotterie wetten. Das heißt: Sie nehmen nicht wirklich an der eigentlichen Lotterie teil, sondern geben nur einen Tipp ab, wie diese ausgehen wird. Sinnvoll ist es, einen Casino Bonus in die Spielstrategie einzubauen. Bekommen Sie Guthaben vom Online Casino zum Plinko spielen „geschenkt“, sollten Sie immer zugreifen. Anmerken wollen wir aber, dass Plinko vielfach in den Bonusbedingungen ausgeschlossen ist. Da Sie beim Plinko teilweise mit jedem Ball einen Gewinn erzielen, können Sie den Rollover mit sehr wenig Risiko meistern. Die Plinko Regeln widersprechen den Bonusmechanismen in den Online Casinos. Einige der besten Plinko Casinos rechnen das Game aber anteilig zum Rollover an.
    https://cutt.us/bNFXm
    Und mit einem Clash.GG-Partnercode verdienst du mehr, was du zu deinen Gewinnen hinzufügen und dein Spielkonto aufstocken kannst. Kopiere diesen Promo-Code noch heute und löse ihn auf Clash.GG ein, um dein CS-Spielerlebnis zu verbessern. Get rewarded for every visit with our Loyalty Loot FREE Slot Play Giveaway on Friday, June 27! The more you visit, the more entries you’ll earn! You’ll receive one entry for every day you played with your Island Passport Club card from June 27, 2024-June 15, 2025. Starting Monday, June 16, you’ll receive one FREE entry each day you visit an Island Passport Club kiosk. You can also earn five additional entries every day from June 23-26 by playing with your Island Passport Club card. Legale Casinos mit Plinko kannst du als Spieler aus Deutschland nicht ansteuern. Die Casinos mit einer Lizenz der deutschen Behörden dürfen dir ausschließlich Spielautomaten und einigen Fällen Tischspiele wie Roulette anbieten. Plinko gibt es in den Casinos jedoch nicht.

    Reply

  111. 18+. T&C is van toepassing. | Play Regal Casino. Andere populaire livespellen zijn Mega Roulette, Mega Wheel, ONE Blackjack, Lightning Roulette en Monopoly Live – maar dat is slechts het topje van de ijsberg. Als kers op de taart biedt JACKS.NL je nu een fantastische kans om gratis mee te doen met de Super bet actie. Wanneer je je aanmeldt bij het Superbet casino online, ontvang je een gratis €100 free bet. Dit bedrag kun je inzetten op een Superbet van jouw keuze, wat het is maakt niet uit; sportweddenschappen of een van de spannende casinospellen. Om gebruik te maken van deze website moet je 24 jaar of ouder zijn Bij het spelen van Bonanza via verschillende online aanbieders kunnen de voorwaarden rondom bonussen en promotiecodes sterk variëren. Sommige casino’s koppelen specifieke promoties aan slechts één spel, wat betekent dat een bonus enkel gebruikt kan worden bij het spelen van SweetBonanza. Dit kan aantrekkelijk zijn voor spelers die zich volledig willen richten op deze populaire slot.
    https://mediasuitedata.clariah.nl/user/rafsarunslan1973
    Als fan van Candy Crush Saga heb ik bij het testen van Sweet Bonanza heel wat lol gehad: de gameplay en ambiance doen namelijk sterk denken aan dit verslavende spelletje vol snoepgoed.  Beschikbare betaalmethodes Wat is je leeftijd? Nee, de Sweet Bonanza app is niet betrouwbaar. De kans is groot dat je geen geld verdient, maar juist geld verliest. Ook is de app illegaal. Download deze dus niet. Meneer Casino is verplicht te vragen hoe oud je bent. Maar maak je geen zorgen: je hebt altijd toegang tot de website, ongeacht je leeftijd. In de Kansino’s casino app wachten een verscheidenheid aan tafelspellen op jouw ontdekking. Je kunt genieten van klassiekers zoals blackjack en roulette, maar ook van baccarat, poker en craps. Wat het nog gaver maakt, is dat je van veel van deze spellen verschillende varianten kunt vinden in de app. Of je nu tegen de computer speelt of live, de keuze is aan jou.

    Reply

  112. The right to erasure – You have the right to request that we erase your personal data, under certain conditions. As previously mentioned, TeenPatti Gold is based on the Indian card game known as Teen Patti, which is influenced by three-card brag and poker. Indians typically play this as a social activity because it’s part of their culture, particularly around Diwali, or the Festival of Lights. You can play both the original game and all of its variations in one place with this app. Teen_Patti_Dhamal_v3.2.1.apk 3-patti-india-star-online_v1.0.apk Decide whether you want to play Teen Patti for fun or if you’re interested in real-money gaming. There are numerous online platforms and mobile apps that offer Teen Patti games. Experience Traditional Teen Patti with Modern Flair दोस्तों अगर आप लोग भी New Rummy Application को डाउनलोड करने में रुचि रखते हैं और आप लोग भी रमी गेम खेलने के शौकीन है, तो आप लोग RummyBonusApp.Com के माध्यम से इन सभी एप्लीकेशंस को डाउनलोड कर सकते हैं,
    https://www.recepti.com/profile/view/126955
    So, random quick stabs of elation or disgust are how it goes in Pirate Bonanza. And to be fair, the game is technically capable of dropping sizable multiplier values in abundance on the grid to build an exciting total multiplier, which is why its 10,000x the bet max win is achievable in all game modes. Tallied up, when Pirate Bonanza is raging, it is able to cross swords with some of the bigger, scarier contenders in the scatter-paying arena. From the hottest games to bold flavors to year-round must-see entertainment, this is where West Michigan comes to experience the best. You can find the best free online slots here on this page. At Casino.org we’ve rated hundreds of free online slot machines and every month we update this page with the best free slots games in the market. Nine regular paying symbols land throughout. There are 6 gems as the lower value symbols, then a bottle, a map, a compass, and a hat as the 4 higher value symbols. When 8 identical symbols are in view, the payout comes to 0.1 to 1 times the bet. When 19+ matching symbols hit, players collect 50 to 400 times their stake. Not hugely surprising, given Pirate Bonanza is a scatter-paying slot, wild symbols do not land in the game at any time.

    Reply

  139. Live casino Indonesia [url=https://betawinindo.top/#]Slot gacor Beta138[/url] Situs judi resmi berlisensi

    Reply

  146. Situs judi online terpercaya Indonesia [url=https://mandiwinindo.site/#]Bonus new member 100% Mandiribet[/url] Mandiribet

    Reply

  149. Abutogel login [url=https://abutowin.icu/#]Bandar togel resmi Indonesia[/url] Situs togel online terpercaya

    Reply

  153. Yeni az?rbaycan kazino sayt? [url=https://pinwinaz.pro/#]Slot oyunlar? Pinco-da[/url] Pinco casino mobil t?tbiq

    Reply

  158. Bandar togel resmi Indonesia [url=https://abutowin.icu/#]Jackpot togel hari ini[/url] Link alternatif Abutogel

    Reply

  165. Jiliko login [url=https://jilwin.pro/#]Jiliko bonus[/url] Jiliko casino walang deposit bonus para sa Pinoy

    Reply

  168. Situs togel online terpercaya [url=https://abutowin.icu/#]Jackpot togel hari ini[/url] Bandar togel resmi Indonesia

    Reply

  182. Mexican Pharmacy Hub [url=http://mexicanpharmacyhub.com/#]Mexican Pharmacy Hub[/url] Mexican Pharmacy Hub

    Reply

  183. Mexican Pharmacy Hub [url=https://mexicanpharmacyhub.shop/#]best prices on finasteride in mexico[/url] Mexican Pharmacy Hub

    Reply

  186. gabapentin mexican pharmacy [url=https://mexicanpharmacyhub.com/#]Mexican Pharmacy Hub[/url] buy meds from mexican pharmacy

    Reply

  188. Mexican Pharmacy Hub [url=http://mexicanpharmacyhub.com/#]Mexican Pharmacy Hub[/url] Mexican Pharmacy Hub

    Reply

  213. CardioMeds Express [url=https://cardiomedsexpress.com/#]lasix 100 mg tablet[/url] lasix furosemide 40 mg

    Reply

  215. TrustedMeds Direct [url=https://trustedmedsdirect.shop/#]amoxicillin without a prescription[/url] TrustedMeds Direct

    Reply

  218. TrustedMeds Direct [url=http://trustedmedsdirect.com/#]amoxicillin online without prescription[/url] order amoxicillin online no prescription

    Reply

  228. Podstawowe informacje o casino online Vavada: Parametr – Opis, Rok założenia: 2017, Licencja: Curaçao (RN 143168), Właściciel: Vavada B.V. (zarejestrowana na Cyprze) Oferta gier: Ponad 5000 tytułów: sloty, gry stołowe, stoły z krupierami na żywo

    Reply

  245. medicaments generiques et originaux France [url=https://pharmaexpressfrance.com/#]pharmacie en ligne france[/url] pharmacie en ligne pas cher

    Reply

  249. kamagra 100 mg prix competitif en ligne [url=http://pharmalibrefrance.com/#]acheter kamagra pas cher livraison rapide[/url] kamagra oral jelly

    Reply

  255. kamagra en ligne France sans ordonnance [url=https://pharmalibrefrance.shop/#]kamagra oral jelly[/url] PharmaLibre

    Reply

  259. cialis sans ordonnance [url=http://intimapharmafrance.com/#]tadalafil 20 mg en ligne[/url] commander cialis discretement

    Reply

  275. Daftar InaTogel Login Link Alternatif Terbaru [url=https://linklist.bio/inatogelbrand#]Daftar InaTogel Login Link Alternatif Terbaru[/url] Daftar InaTogel Login Link Alternatif Terbaru

    Reply

  299. UK pharmacy home delivery [url=https://mediquickuk.shop/#]trusted UK digital pharmacy[/url] online pharmacy UK no prescription

    Reply

  308. cialis online UK no prescription [url=https://intimacareuk.shop/#]buy ED pills online discreetly UK[/url] IntimaCareUK

    Reply

  312. generic sildenafil UK pharmacy [url=https://bluepilluk.com/#]viagra discreet delivery UK[/url] viagra online UK no prescription

    Reply

  321. generic sildenafil UK pharmacy [url=https://bluepilluk.com/#]viagra discreet delivery UK[/url] viagra online UK no prescription

    Reply

  357. ohne rezept apotheke [url=https://gesunddirekt24.shop/#]gunstige medikamente direkt bestellen[/url] medikament ohne rezept notfall

    Reply

  366. medikamente rezeptfrei [url=https://potenzapothekede.com/#]rezeptfreie medikamente fur erektionsstorungen[/url] cialis generika ohne rezept

    Reply

  369. gГјnstige online apotheke [url=https://potenzapothekede.shop/#]schnelle lieferung tadalafil tabletten[/url] PotenzApotheke

    Reply

  377. Viagra rezeptfreie Schweiz bestellen [url=http://intimgesund.com/#]generisches sildenafil alternative[/url] generisches sildenafil alternative

    Reply

  383. Viagra Tabletten für Männer [url=http://intimgesund.com/#]generisches sildenafil alternative[/url] kamagra erfahrungen deutschland

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Stuartpef Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Arinze Kene – A Star in the Making

Next Story

British Dogs of War or International Terrorists?

Latest from Blog