Dark
Light

Suggestions

Serena Williams and the Politics of Hate(rs)

January 13, 2024
8 mins read

BLACKNESS AND STARDOM
 
 
By David J. Leonard |with thanks to NewBlackMan
 
Saturday, January 14, 2012.
 
Following a first-round victory in the Brisbane International tournament, Serena Williams expressed her sentiments about tennis, sport, and her labor of unlove.   “I mean, I don’t love tennis today, but I’m here, and I can’t live without it … so I’m still here and I don’t want to go anywhere any time soon,” she explained. “It’s not that I’ve fallen out of love; I’ve actually never liked sports, and I never understood how I became an athlete. I don’t like working out; I don’t like anything that has to do with working physically.”  Williams comments, not surprisingly, elicited widespread commentary, most of which used her confession as a source of criticism and demonization.
 
In “Woe is Serena: Tennis star says she doesn’t love tennis,” Chris Chase criticizes Williams as narcissistic and otherwise incapable of being self-reflective and self-critical.  While acknowledging her candor, he uses that candor as a source of condemnation:
 
From one view, her candor could be seen as refreshing. Here’s a top athlete discussing the delicate balance of passion and obligation and fear of the unknown. She’s revealing herself to the press, something she rarely has in the past. Then you step back and realize Serena has the least self-awareness of any great athlete of the past decade. Two years later, she can’t bring herself to acknowledge that she was wrong to threaten a lineswoman at the U.S. Open. She’ll likely never admit her actions in last year’s U.S. Open final crossed the line. Unless she gained some insight in the past four months, these quotes are selfish nonsense.
 
Chase, unwilling to limit the criticisms to the quote, rehashes and recycles those previous incidences that in his mind provide context for understanding Serena’s dislike of tennis.  In other words, just as she violated the rules of tennis, just as she has been unable to apologize for her past missed deeds, and just as she hasn’t been able to acknowledge her own faults, these comments are construed as evidence of her deficiencies as a person and athlete.  Chase goes on to argue:
 
Nobody is surprised Serena doesn’t like tennis. Like Andre Agassi before her, she seems to only love the winning and is willing to put up with what it takes to get there. The grind doesn’t interest her much. These aren’t new insights into her soul. The underlying tone isn’t that Serena is a reluctant sports hero, it’s that she’s able to be so much better than the rest of the tour without caring about the game like they do. Her “I don’t love tennis” quote isn’t a revelation, it’s a self-congratulatory declaration. It’s as if she’s saying, “Just imagine what I could do if I cared.”
 
Pete Bodo, with “The real question facing Serena Williams,” expresses a bit more sympathy given Williams’ litany of injuries.   Yet, he still concludes: “Serena’s problem appears to be that she likes the reward (celebrity and money) but not the process. She would like to win the Australian title and any number of other tournaments, but she hates having to go through the motions – you know, the long practice sessions, the diet, the gym workouts and even that messy business of playing matches. It’s not a good problem to have, at least not for an athlete.”  Beyond the efforts to link her comments to selfishness and a sense of victimhood, several commentaries link her disinterest with tennis to her diverse interests (fashion specifically), as if that is a shortcoming. 
 
More instructively and disturbingly are the comments that are found alongside many of the articles.  Here are a few examples
 
 
Scar City: It shows what an idiot she really is. Because if it weren’t for sport, she’d be sitting on her increasingly fat bum, watching the shopping channel, buying cheap junk, because she became too fat to leave the house !….(and I have no doubt her expensive “Tastes” are as bad as anyone else’s poor tastes)………She’s vile !
 
DanielaCG: No amount of shopping or trying to act feminine could change the fact that she looks like a beast!
 
etweinberg: How ungrateful can one person be? I would do anything to have that kind of natural talent in a professional sport. Are we supposed to feel sorry for her? “Awww, Serena….you don’t like your job that you get paid millions of dollars to do. Poor, poor girl…..”  Considering the way the economy is right now, with all the social unrest because of it…..pretty bad timing, I’d say.
 
Elijabeam: Serena’s movement reminds me of a cow grazing over a filed for grass, but what do you expect at 30 if you don’t practice or train?? She has taken soo much integrity away from the sport, it’s nice to not see so many double standards anymore!!
 
Chris.Klarner: She plays because she’s built like a man and can over power the other woman playing. She’s a fat piece of trash and proved it with her comment.
 
Mslewis: The fact that Serena does not like tennis has not been much of a secret for a very long time. She has been out of shape and listless for years now and the only reason she wins matches is because she’s bigger and hits harder than most of the women.  When she is ahead she looks   totally bored and goes through the motions, but when her opponent shows some spark and beats up on her, Serena just gives in.  (See: U.S. Open 2011 final)
 
I believe Serena hangs around because her “acting” career hasn’t worked out nor has her “designing” career, so what else will keep her in the spotlight . . . tennis.  Either that or she has run out of money because she and Venus support her large family of hangers on and she needs to continue to play for the money she gets from exhibitions, endorsements, etc.
 
Her father said years ago that he hoped Serena and Venus would retire before they turned 30.  Guess that hasn’t worked out the way he thought.  Whatever!  Cry me a river.
 
What is striking about the comments and several of the commentaries as well, is the demonization of Serena Williams.  Focusing on her body (reinforced by the many pictures that sexualize Williams), her attitude, and her shortcomings as a player, the responses pathologize Williams.  “The Williams sisters have been criticized for lacking ‘commitment’ by refusing to conform to the Spartan training regime of professional tennis, restricting their playing schedules, having too many ‘off-court interests’ in acting, music, product endorsements, fashion and interior design, and their Jehovah’s Witness religion” (McKay and Johnson).  Her comments here are merely positioned as evidence for the longstanding criticism.
 
The subtext is even more instructive with so much focus on her body.  For many, Williams is a wasted talent, as someone whose laziness, lack of work ethnic, limited dedication, and absent focus has precluded her from reaching her greatness.  The ample discussion about her body as evidence of her lack of commitment illustrates the profound ways that these comments are used to authenticate the narrative of Serena Williams as failure.  This is nothing new as tennis commentators and fans alike have long criticized her as fat, out-of-shape, and otherwise lack commitment to be great. “The Williams sisters also have been subjected to the carping critical gaze that both structures and is a key discursive theme of ‘pornographic eroticism’,” writes James McKay and Helen Johnson.  Similarly, Delia Douglas argues, a “particular version of blackness” is advanced within the representations of the Williams sisters.  We see the “essentialist logic of racial difference, which has long sought to mark the black body as inherently different from other bodies.  Characterizations of their style of play rely on ‘a very ancient grammar’ of black physicality to explain their athletic success”
 
What also guides these comments is the ways in which Williams has been celebrated as evidence of the American Dream – because of tennis she was able to secure tremendous wealth and success, otherwise unavailable to her.  The anger and condemnation embodies this belief that without sports Serena Williams would be working at McDonalds or some other minimum wage job.  Guided by narratives of race and class, Williams is thus reimagined as ungrateful, as disrespectful to what the game “has given her.”  In many respects, this explains the very different reaction to the similar comments from Andre Agassi.  Agassi, as white male, is seen to have had many options in life to secure the American Dream, whereas Williams is render incapable of success outside the realm of sport prompting this sort of demonization.   
 
McKay and Johnson offer important analysis in this regard, noting how the long history of demonization is very much connected to a narrative of the American Dream
 
They have been constructed within a ‘ghetto-to-glory’ narrative: a journalist referred to their ascent as a ‘fairy tale, that astonishing narrative of the ‘‘ghetto Cinderellas’’ ’ (Adams, 2005), one described Venus as a former ‘teenage curio from a Los Angeles ghetto’ (Muscat, 2007), and another stated that, ‘Only in America would Venus have risen from her cradle of crack dealers and grunge courts to contest the women’s singles final at Wimbledon’ (Mott, 2000). Patton (2001, p. 122) refers to these sorts of narratives as ‘an Africanized version of the Horatio Alger story in which athletics provides a route out of the ghetto’.
 
The reactionary discourse and the outrage that has surrounded Serena’s recent comments is a testament to the ways in which the Williams sisters have been imagined “an Africanized version of the Horatio Alger story in which athletics provides a route out of the ghetto’.”  Her purported refusal to accept and be grateful for the fantasy narrative is the source of outrage.  Her refusal to substantiate the narrative of sport as great equalizer compels the demonization.   
 
Clearly the outrage directed at Serena Williams reflects a systemic erasure of the labor of athletes.  Whether in reference to collegiate or professional athletes, dominant narratives ubiquitously erase the labor and the conditions of labor under which athletes work.  By imagining sport as game, fun, and hobby, the hard work, the dedication, the sacrifice, the pain, and exploitation are all rendered invisible.  “The truth is, sports is labor, most of it invisible. (Even the visible labor — weightlifting, workouts, wearisome travel — is mostly invisible to the public.),” writes Steve Rushin.  “When a guy is sitting on a stool, staring into space in a state of semi-dress, he is almost always working. This is the kind of work done by a starting pitcher on game day, when nobody goes near him, or by a writer jackknifed over his keyboard, nibbling his thumbnail to a nubbin.”  The denied work of athletes is exacerbated by race and gender given the ways in which white supremacy and patriarchy leaves the work of black women invisible.
 
The invisibility and erasure is quite evident with both the shock and outrage over Serena Williams’ recent confession.  Whereas others see tennis as sport, game, activity, hobby, Serena makes clear that tennis is labor; it is handwork; it is injury; in many regards it is an assault on her subjectivity. Tennis, a job, ain’t nothing but work.  In reminding people that tennis is a job, a tough one that she doesn’t like and has never liked, Williams powerfully challenges those who see her identity as determined by her profession. 
 
***
David J. Leonard is Associate Professor in the Department of Critical Culture, Gender and Race Studies at Washington State University, Pullman. He has written on sport, video games, film, and social movements, appearing in both popular and academic mediums. His work explores the political economy of popular culture, examining the interplay between racism, state violence, and popular representations through contextual, textual, and subtextual analysis.  Leonard’s latest book After Artest: Race and the Assault on Blackness will be published by SUNY Press in May of 2012.
 

  Send to a friend  |  

View/Hide Comments (0)   |  

  Print

Post Views: 461

108 Comments

  8. лучшие айти университеты
    казахстана, лучшие it университеты казахстана 2023 ертедегі адамдар
    палеоантроптар, адам эволюциясының негізгі кезеңдері презентация
    қазақтың ұлттық ойындары ағылшынша, қазақтың ұлттық ойындары қол күрес ә дыбысы
    мен әрпі мектепалды даярлық, ә дыбысы мен әрпі қмж

    Reply

  11. бақа мен адам қан жасушаларының ұқсастығы,
    адам мен бақа қанының айырмашылығы
    біз біргеміз рухты ән скачать, казагым кайда скачать химия 8 сынып электронды оқулық,
    химия 10 сынып электронды оқулық 2
    бөлім коэффициент марокко франция, 1xbet

    Reply

  12. оқыту үрдісі дегеніміз не, оқыту үрдісінің моделі саясаттану пәнінің маған қосқан үлесі, саясаттану
    негіздері әкесі 28 жаста ұлы 6
    да, асан 11 жаста, ал үсен 1 жаста экологияның адамға әсері, қоршаған ортаның адам
    денсаулығына әсері

    Reply

  13. прикольные клички собак девочке, клички для
    собак девочкам со значением слушать молитву к чистому четвергу послушать молитвы за болящего
    если снится крокодил к чему это женщине к чему снится корова женщине исламский сонник

    Reply

  14. гороскоп телец на 3 дня совместимость знаков зодиака
    одинаковых полов зодиак конец света
    к чему сниться женщина по исламскому соннику бизнес гадание на картах, расклад таро на успех дела

    Reply

  46. adderall canadian pharmacy [url=http://expressrxcanada.com/#]Generic drugs from Canada[/url] pet meds without vet prescription canada

    Reply

  49. Rx Express Mexico [url=https://rxexpressmexico.shop/#]Rx Express Mexico[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

    Reply

  53. legit canadian pharmacy [url=https://expressrxcanada.shop/#]Buy medicine from Canada[/url] my canadian pharmacy reviews

    Reply

  56. mexico pharmacy order online [url=https://rxexpressmexico.com/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] mexico pharmacy order online

    Reply

  85. Over the counter antibiotics for infection [url=https://biotpharm.shop/#]Biot Pharm[/url] buy antibiotics from india

    Reply

  89. buy antibiotics from india [url=https://biotpharm.com/#]BiotPharm[/url] best online doctor for antibiotics

    Reply

  95. Over the counter antibiotics pills [url=https://biotpharm.shop/#]buy antibiotics online uk[/url] buy antibiotics from india

    Reply

  104. Play online Slingo, which takes a standard online slot machine and gives it a bingo twist. The more Slingos you collect, the more valuable the prizes are on the prize ladder. We’ve created this page so you can easily find the best online casinos that payout in the USA. Not all casinos are equal, and many of the industry’s top sites differ from the competition by stocking high RTP casino games, including the latest online slots and live table games. The best payout online casinos that feature games with a lower house edge provide players with a much higher chance of winning, making for a much more thrilling experience.  If you love to win big, CoolCat Casino delivers with jackpots totaling in the millions. The great thing about our real money slots jackpots is that many of them pop randomly when you least expect it. That means a spin that resulted in no payout could lead to more money than you know what to do with!
    https://pureindustrialchemical.com/how-useful-is-the-free-demo-mode-in-mines-game/
    EGT Digital continues to expand its presence in Italy after the local operator Diecimilauno S.p.A. added the provider’s gaming content to its betting site Zonagioco. Currently its visitors are able to try their luck with titles from the jackpot top-performers Bell Link, High Cash and Clover Chance, with integration of the other games from the Bulgarian company’s portfolio expected in the near future. Hongqiao World Center, 1588 Zhuguang Road, Qingpu District, Shanghai, 201106, P.R.C On Christmas Day, he bet himself into another jam. Losses on the day’s football games mounted, spurning him to search for overseas basketball games to wager on after the family went to bed. Needing to win big, he bet big: $1,000 on an overseas game in which he didn’t know the names of the players or where the teams were from.

    Reply

  105. L’azienda ha un centro di sviluppo e uffici in Europa e ha stabilito una solida rete di partnership in Asia, nella CSI, America Latina ed Europa. Questo conferma la sua presenza globale e la capacità di raggiungere diverse regioni con i suoi prodotti di alta qualità. Il Penalty Shoot Out Casino Bet Game è alimentato da un motore di gioco altamente avanzato che assicura un gameplay fluido e reattivo. Il motore è progettato per gestire il processo decisionale in tempo reale, consentendo ai giocatori di sperimentare un’azione dinamica e veloce senza ritardi o ritardi. Il potente backend non solo migliora gli effetti visivi e audio, ma assicura anche che ogni tiro e risultato venga elaborato all’istante, offrendo un’esperienza più coinvolgente e coinvolgente. Il motore del gioco è molto leggero e consente di utilizzarlo su un touch screen.
    https://bellizaskincare.com/strategie-vincenti-per-aumentare-le-probabilita-su-aviator_1748418580/
    The structure is designed to play FootBowl in compliance with the rules of the game. Vinícius Júnior, who also came under scrutiny for taunting Atlético supporters about his Champions League titles after missing a penalty, has escaped punishment entirely. Dive into Penalty Shoot-Out Street today and see if you have what it takes to score the ultimate jackpot. With its captivating design and rewarding features, this game is a must-try for anyone seeking a blend of sports and slots. Ceballos, the former Arsenal loanee who is racing to be fit for the game, was also fined £17,000 for what UEFA described as violations of the “basic rules of decent conduct.” We recommend logging in to save your lightbox We recommend logging in to save your lightbox The downside of trying to pass out from the back in such an orchestrated manner is the possibility of losing possession in a dangerous area.

    Reply

  106. Jeśli chcesz wypróbować aplikację Aviator Predyktor bez wydawania pieniędzy, oferujemy bezpłatną wersję. Ważne jest, aby pamiętać, że dokładne przewidywanie wyniku gry Aviator, nawet wraz z pojawiającymi się predyktorami internetowymi, nie jest tak łatwe, jak się wydaje. 4. System Labouchera: Jeden z najbardziej skomplikowanych systemów obstawiania do gry Aviator, Aviatrixi Szczęściarz Jet. Podczas samodzielnego wykonywania obliczeń łatwo się pogubić i popełnić błędy. Z kalkulatorem 1Win w języku rosyjskim nie jesteś w niebezpieczeństwie! Nasz kalkulator sportowy wykorzystuje algorytmy i formuły obliczeniowe, więc ich dokładność nie jest kwestionowana! Aviator to jedna z najpopularniejszych gier crash na 1win India. Mnożnik rośnie z każdą sekundą, a Ty musisz wypłacić pieniądze, zanim samolot się rozbije. Z rundami trwającymi poniżej 10 sekund, jest idealna do szybkiej, pełnej adrenaliny gry.
    https://en.sfml-dev.org/forums/index.php?action=profile;area=summary;u=34157
    Betano kasyno jest idealna dla tych, którzy rozważają demo Lucky Jet. Z grami od slotów po gry stołowe, wszystkie z opcją darmowej gry, możesz poznać stronę bez obaw o utratę własnych pieniędzy. «Aviator» w MostBet ma proste i nieskomplikowane zasady. Aby z powodzeniem grać w ten slot: Aviator online to gra, w której obstawiasz rosnące kursy, które zależą od wysokości lecącego samolotu. Im dłużej czekasz, tym więcej możesz wygrać, ale jeśli nie zdążysz wycofać zakładu przed odlotem samolotu, tracisz wszystko. Gra pojawiła się w styczniu 2019 roku i została opracowana przez Spribe, firmę specjalizującą się w innowacyjnych rozwiązaniach gamingowych. Aviator szybko zyskał popularność wśród graczy na całym świecie dzięki dynamicznej i ekscytującej rozgrywce, a także wysokiemu współczynnikowi wypłat. Działa w oparciu o system provably fair, który zapewnia, że wyniku każdej rundy nie można przewidzieć ani sfałszować. Automat posiada następujące funkcje:

    Reply

  107. Sweet Bonanza Dice is a colorful slot with cascading mechanics and colorful candies as symbols. Sweet Bonanza Dice slot is played on six reels in five rows, winnings are formed using clusters. Sweet Bonanza Dice slot has free spins, multipliers, and a bonus bet that will increase the chances of triggering free spins. Sweet Bonanza Turkey is a popular online slot game that has captured the attention of many players. It offers a fun and colorful gaming experience with a variety of tasty symbols like candies and fruits. The game is easy to play, making it perfect for both beginners and experienced players. Sweet Bonanza Turkey features exciting bonus rounds and multipliers that can boost your winnings. With its vibrant graphics and engaging gameplay, it has quickly become a favorite among online slot enthusiasts in Turkey. Players enjoy the thrill and rewards that Sweet Bonanza Demo Turkish delivers.
    https://swaay.com/u/ciafofemea197736616/about/
    COPYRIGHT © 2015 – 2025. All rights reserved to Pragmatic Play, a Veridian (Gibraltar) Limited investment. Any and all content included on this website or incorporated by reference is protected by international copyright laws. In this expert slot review of Sweet Bonanza by Pragmatic Play, we evaluated the full suite of gameplay features you can try for free in demo play. Our experts have studied game mechanics, the theme, bonuses, and all the pros and cons of choosing this slot. Additionally, we prepared a list of licensed and tested online casinos where you can play this game for real money. This Sweet Bonanza slot features the popular tumbling reels mechanism, meaning that winning combos disappear after landing on the reels and are replaced with other symbols falling from above. If a new winning combo is created from symbols then the tumble continues until there are no new wins to be had, the total win is then added to your balance.

    Reply

  108. Sweet Bonanza is more than just a typical slot game; it’s a vivid, engaging experience that has captivated Canadian gamers with its candy-themed allure and multiple winning opportunities. Its combination of visually appealing graphics, innovative gameplay mechanics, and the potential for significant payouts makes it a standout choice in the world of online slots. As a Canadian sensation, Sweet Bonanza offers an enthralling escape into a world of vibrant colors and exciting possibilities. Sweet Bonanza offers a distinctive 6×5 grid layout, differing from the usual slot configurations. Players love the ‘All Ways Pay’ mechanic, enabling winning combinations by matching symbols anywhere on the reels. This feature increases winning opportunities and keeps the gameplay dynamic.
    https://data.openstate.eu/es_AR/user/demorsiram1976
    The Razzies don’t care about your A-list status, but then I feel oppressed. Interactions of Big Bass Bonanza Hold and Spinner depending on spins games coming from a range of leading software providers are a definite plus and make things even more engaging, as the tribe intends to build the casino on community trust land just outside the southern border of Chandler. 1Big Bass Bonanza Megaways The Razzies don’t care about your A-list status, but then I feel oppressed. Interactions of Big Bass Bonanza Hold and Spinner depending on spins games coming from a range of leading software providers are a definite plus and make things even more engaging, as the tribe intends to build the casino on community trust land just outside the southern border of Chandler. Ed abroad is the trusted study abroad consultant in Ernakulam Kochi, fully committed to providing free study overseas consultation for students looking for overseas education. We support the students by providing the up to date information and offering our assistance in completing Application formalities, Visa guidance, Scholarship Guidance, and assistance for Educational loans.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to aqtdncsfy Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Michael Rapaport’s Documentary on ‘A Tribe Called Quest’ Comes to Britain

Next Story

On Returning to A Parent’s Final Place of Rest

Latest from Blog